Introduction: Common Violations in SEC Enforcement Actions
When the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) brings an enforcement action for an illegal private securities offering, the most common allegations involve fraud, misrepresentation, and failure to comply with registration or exemption requirements. Three of the most frequently cited provisions are:
- Section 10(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934
- Rule 10b-5 under the Exchange Act
- Section 17(a) of the Securities Act of 1933
These rules prohibit fraudulent or deceptive conduct in connection with the offer or sale of securities, including:
- Making false or misleading statements to investors
- Omitting material facts that a reasonable investor would consider important
- Engaging in any scheme or device to defraud
- Failing to properly disclose risks, fees, or conflicts of interest
- Using investor funds for purposes inconsistent with offering documents
In cases where the SEC believes investors have been misled, even unintentionally, it can pursue significant penalties—including disgorgement of all funds raised, civil fines, injunctions, and bans on future securities involvement. Below is an overview of the consequences a person or entity may face when found to have violated these provisions.
1. Disgorgement of Ill-Gotten Gains
The SEC can seek disgorgement, which means you must return any money obtained through the unlawful offering.
This includes all profits or proceeds from the offering that were derived through misrepresentation, omission, or any deceptive practice.
The amount is typically equal to the total amount raised unlawfully, plus prejudgment interest.
Even if funds were spent or lost, you’re still liable for the full amount.
Example: If you raised $3 million from investors using misleading statements, the SEC may seek the return of the full $3 million plus interest—even if the money is no longer available.
2. Civil Monetary Penalties
In addition to disgorgement, the SEC can impose civil fines under a three-tier penalty structure. These penalties can apply per violation, and a single offering may include multiple violations if there are several investors or misstatements.
Tier 1 (Basic Violations):
- Up to $12,921 per violation for individuals
- Up to $129,213 per violation for companies
Tier 2 (Involving Fraud or Reckless Conduct):
- Up to $129,213 per violation for individuals
- Up to $646,067 per violation for companies
Tier 3 (Fraud with Substantial Loss or Risk to Investors):
- Up to $258,426 per violation for individuals
- Up to $1,292,136 per violation for companies
Important: Each misstatement or affected investor can count as a separate violation, multiplying total exposure.
3. Permanent Injunctions
A court may impose a permanent injunction against you, which legally bars you from engaging in future violations of the securities laws.
This is a serious court order—violating it can result in contempt charges or even criminal prosecution.
It is a permanent stain on your regulatory record and can limit future fundraising and business opportunities—even in the private markets.
4. Disqualification from Future Private Offerings
If the SEC finds that you engaged in egregious misconduct—such as fraud, misrepresentation, or willful violations of securities laws—it can seek civil injunctions and bars that may not only damage your reputation but also disqualify you from conducting future private securities offerings.
Under Rule 506(d) of Regulation D, certain “bad actor” events will disqualify you—and potentially your entire company—from using the Rule 506(b) or 506(c) exemptions. These disqualifying events include:
- Being subject to a court injunction for violating securities laws
- Being barred by the SEC from participating in securities offerings
- Being the subject of certain final orders issued by regulators (state or federal)
- Being suspended or expelled from a registered national securities association
This means that if you, or anyone considered a “covered person” (like a managing member, executive officer, director, general partner, or 20% owner), is hit with one of these sanctions, you may no longer be able to raise capital legally using Regulation D.
In plain terms: A single enforcement action could permanently shut down your ability to raise private money—even if your business remains private and never intends to go public.
Other Possible Consequences
- State enforcement actions may follow SEC action, creating additional penalties.
- Private lawsuits may be filed by investors, seeking damages under federal or state securities laws.
- Reputational damage may affect your ability to raise capital or maintain investor relationships in the future.
- Loss of licenses or professional affiliations may occur depending on your industry or credentials.
Conclusion
If you’re raising money through private offerings—whether for real estate syndications, investment funds, or your privately held business—compliance isn’t optional. The SEC has made clear that even private issuers are subject to strict anti-fraud rules and can face crippling penalties for misstatements, omissions, or improper offering practices.
Violating securities laws—even unintentionally—can result in:
- Full disgorgement of capital raised
- Civil penalties reaching millions of dollars
- Permanent injunctions
- Personal liability
- And most devastating of all—disqualification from ever raising capital again under Regulation D
At SyndicationAttorneys.com, we specialize in helping private issuers stay on the right side of the law. Whether you’re forming your first fund, launching a syndicate, or scaling a capital-raising platform, our team knows the legal landscape—and how to protect you in it.
Thinking about raising capital?
Talk to us before you talk to investors.
